www.byzcath.org Forums Faith & Christian Life Prayer Terri Schiavo

The federal judge has denied the request to reinsert Terri's feedling tube.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/7254897/

After hearing what I heard from Bob Schindler on TV this morning, I am solidly on the side of Terri, no quavering, now. So that's what Mikey Schiavo has been up to! and no living will to prove that Terri did not want extraordinary measures to keep her alive.
What I am proud of is David Gibbs and his work. I graduated from Temple Baptist Seminary in 2002 (Magna cum Laude)Mr. Gibbs was presented with an honorary doctorate at the time. I am sure that he might get criticism from certain Fundamentalist circles for standing by a Catholic family, as he as a rule works almost exclusively with Independent Baptist churches and causes, but he is high in my estimation, now. God bless David Gibbs!
Much Love,
Jonn

The "Order" issued by US District Judge James Whittemore denying the Schindler's petition for a temporary injunctive relief (re-insertion of feeding tube) is now under appeal in Atlanta before the 11th District of the U.S. Court of Appeals. Since it is an emergency appeal, it will be considered and decided by a 3-Judge Panel.

This is an appeal on the procedural rights of the litigants and it does not involve as yet the merits (or "substance") of Terri's case. Judging (pun intended) from the comments of Judge Whittemore during the oral arguments in open court as reported in the media, especially those directed to the counsel of the Schindlers, Terri's cause at this juncture is not rosy at all.

Judge Whittemore's comments are now reflected in his "Order" denying the petition, based on the failure of the petitioners (the Schindlers), by and through Atty. Gibbs, to establish "a substantial likelihood of success on the merits" of the case, the first of four requirements for the favorable issuance of a temporary injunction (or temporary restraining order).

Reading Judge Whittemore's "Order," it is well-reasoned and backed by decisions of the U.S. Supreme Court on the same or similar procedural issues.

Now, I have grave doubts whether the 11th District of the U.S. Court of Appeals will disturb the District Judge's findings.

Let us pray that, somehow, the 3-Judge Panel of the 11th Circuit, U.S. Court of Appeals, will see it otherwise. Let's also hope that, if radio news reports just coming in are accurate, the U.S. Department of Justice will file an intervention in this appeal.

It is gut-wrenching to be witnessing Terri's case go through the legal maze while she lies there hungry and thirsting. Lord, have mercy!

The emergecny legislation (an act of mercy) passed by the U.S. Congress and signed into law by Pres. Bush just went for naught!

Amado

The federal appeals court denied the appeal.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com

God have mercy. They are going to kill that poor woman; they are really going to do it. God have mercy.

--John

Lord Jesus Christ, Son of the Living God, through the prayers of the Most Holy Theotokos, have mercy on us and on the whole world. Fogive us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us...Lord have mercy on Terri, her family and supporters, and on all who have struggled through prayer and thoughts asking for mercy.

In the abuandance of you tender mercy Lord as you raised Dorcus from death, as you raised the commanders daughter, as you called Lazarus from the tomb, only you Jesus can call Terri from the tomb. Raise her up on her last day Lord, as all means of man have been exhausted, you alone can help, you alone can save. Let them find her clothed and sitting in her right mind, all faculties restored to her, that the world will see the power of your life giving ressurection in this most holy time of the year. Jesus we know you hear the prayers of your faithful, let it be so now Jesus in this day and time.

In the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, AMEN.

Alas, what a society we are creating: one that aborts its young and kills people who it deems 'not valuable'! We need to weep for our society---but THEN we need to begin to evangelize those around us and spread the word that, GOD LOVES US, DIED FOR US, AND ROSE FROM THE DEAD FOR US...and that He puts great value of ALL LIFE, from the womb to natural death.

Most Holy Mother of God, 'Joy of Those Who Sorrow' pray to your Son for us!

In His great mercy,
+Fr. Gregory

On to the U.S. Supreme Court and/or to Tallahasee at the Florida State Legislature.

The majority decision of the 3-Judge panel of the Federal Appeals Court in Atlanta confirmed our fears.

It dampens our enthusiasm but should strengthen our resolve to pray more fervently for Terri's deliverance.

Let us also pray for the "conversion" of some Florida State legislators who now are being convened to reconsider a proposed law to have the feeding tube re-inserted, unapproved during its last session because of a lack of sufficient votes to pass it.

Further, let us pray that Justice Anthony Kennedy of the U.S. Supreme Court will take the appeal/petition for review of the Appellate Court's decision and alone by himself issue an order or minute resolution countermanding the respective orders of the 2 lower courts or, in the alternative, give a positive recommendation to the other Justices if he decides to refer the case to the Supreme Court en banc.

Furthermore, let us pray that the Supreme Court, Justice Kennedy by himself or en banc, reconsider the dissenting opinion of Federal Appeals Court Judge Charles Wilson who wrote that [Terri] Schiavo's “imminent” death would end the case before it could be fully considered and he failed to see any harm in reinserting the feeding tube. Judge Wilson also observed that the majority failed to consider the "intent" of the U.S. Congress in enacting on Monday the law aimed at preserving the status quo, i.e., the feeding tube stay in place.

Lastly, let us pray that Bob and Mary Schindler and their son and surviving other daughter persevere and do not lose hope in Divine Providence.

Quo vadis, America?

Amado

The Schindlers have chosen to appeal (probably a motion for reconsideration of the decision of the 3-judge panel) to the full 12-member bench of the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals (Atlanta), reserving their next, and probably last, judicial life-line for the U.S. Supreme Court.

I was hoping for this legal maneuver as the dissenting opinion of Appeals Judge Charles Wilson may sway a majority of his co-magistrates.

Let us pray for a positive outcome this time around!

Amado

(Keeping his fingers crossed!)

The 12-judge 11th Circuit Court of Appeals, by a 10-2 decision, has just denied the Schindlers' petition for a re-hearing of their case and an appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court now remains as the only avenue for judicial review of the matter.

Although all previous petitions of the Schindlers were not taken by the U.S. Supreme Court, let us hope and pray that the enactment of "Terri's Law II" by the U.S. Congress and its signing into law by Pres. Bush in the wee hours of last Monday will "force" Justice Anthony Kennedy or the Court en banc to take cognizance of the case and issue a ruling favorable to Terri and her parents thereafter.

But the window of opportunity is fast closing on the Schindlers excepting an emergency legislation by the Florida State Legislature to re-insert Terri's feeding tube or by the exercise of executive privilege either by Gov. Jeb Bush or by Pres. G.W. Bush.

Please join me in continuing to pray for Terri's deliverance.

Amado

Another avenue is closed with the non-approval by the Florida State Senate just an hour ago or so of legislation that would have allowed the re-insertion of Terri's feeding tube.

With that, Gov. Jeb Bush was said to be considering a directive to the DCF to take custody of Terri.

Let us pray that this latest move will materialize fast!

Amado

I'm continuing in my prayers for Terri Schiavo and her family. These are truly horrifying times for our country. If Terri is starved to death what will it say about the moral state of our nation. Terri Schiavo has been denied Holy Communion, and now her family are being searched before being allowed to see her. How dare we say we are one nation under God while allowing this to happen.

The Supreme Court refused to hear the case. Greer is supposed to make a decision at 12:00 EST regarding the state's attempt to take custody of Terri.

~~~For the sick, the suffering, and the captive, let us pray to the Lord!~~~

At this moment, 2 courts are considering the fate of Terri:

First, the State Circuit Court under Judge Greer (yes, the same Judge) is determining whether Florida's DCF, under directive from Gov. Jeb Bush, has the authority and power to take custody of Terri based on "new evidence" of misdiagnosis and probable "mistreatment." A secondary issue is: Can the State take forcible custody of Terri, or of any other person in her situation, if the State deems there is evidence of mistreatment?

Second, the appeal from/petition for review of the 10-2 decison of the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals (Atlanta) has been filed with the U.S. Supreme Court (referred to in some posts/articles as the SCOTUS). It was not clear whether Justice Kennedy will consider the appeal/petition solely by himself or refer it to the Court en banc.

Considering the "history" behind both of these "new" cases, the cards are stacked against Terri and the Schindlers.

We might have one or both decisions at around 12 noon, Eastern Time.

Please, dear Lord, have mercy!

Amado

P.S. YES, AFTER POSTING THE ABOVE, THE U.S. SUPREME COURT JUST DID REJECT THE SCHINDLER'S APPEAL/PETITION IN A TERSE 1-PAGE ORDER AS POINTED OUT BY NON-NOMEN!

I hate to say it, but I think this is a lost cause. It seems clear the courts do not want to deal with this case anymore. Prayers continue, but I am not hopeful. It would take something on the order of the Red Sea parting to make a difference now.

Dear Charles:

Yes, it is very near the end of Terri's judicial life-line!

Amado