www.byzcath.org Forums News & Events Church News Patriarch of Moscow elected

Breaking News -- Kirill Elected New Russian Orthodox Patriarch

The bishops of the Russian Orthodox Church this evening in Moscow elected Metropolitan Kirill of Smolensk and Kaliningrad, 62, to succeed the late Patriarch Alexi II as the head of the Russian Orthodox Church.

The new Patriarch's challenge: to deepen the Church's influence inside Russia, and to widen its presence outside Russia Kirill will "certainly" invite Pope Benedict XVI to visit Russia, and increase collaboration with the Roman Catholic Church worldwide, Orthodox sources say.

His election thus opens new perspectives for closer relations between Orthodoxy and Catholicism, the "two lungs," East and West, of a Christianity divided since the Great Schism of 1054.

His election also opens a new era in the post-Soviet period of the Russian nation, its internal life and its relations to the West and the entire world. A special report

By Robert Moynihan

MOSCOW, JANUARY 27, 2009 -- On the very first day of voting, the bishops of the Russian Orthodox Church this evening elected a new patriarch to succeed the late Patriarch Alexi II, who died in December: Kirill, Metropolitan of Smolensk and Kaliningrad, age 62, according to a reliable source in Moscow.

The vote was more than 600 in favor of Kirill out of some 700 votes, more than 80%, our source said.

This choice, nearly 20 years after the collapse of Soviet communism, marks an epoch in the life of the Russian Church, and of Russia herself.

Kirill, whom I have had the occasion to meet and come to know, is a dynamic person, energetic, decisive. He has deeply-held convictions about his faith, about the role of that faith in the future of his country, and about the role of that faith in the future of Europe and the world. He is persuaded that only a return to "real values" can enable Russia and Europe to confront the current economic and cultural crisis. He believes Russia's greatness, eclipsed in recent years, can only be restored by the renewal of her ancient Orthodox faith.

Therefore, Kirill will attempt a double agenda: (1) to build on what Patriarch Alexi accomplished during the 18 years of his patriarchate, continuing to rebuild the Church's ruined infrastructure (thousands of Orthodox churches have been rebuilt around Russia since 1991); and (2) to launch a series of new initiatives to strengthen the Church's voice and influence in Russian society.

Kirill can be expected, then, to continue rebuilding Russian churches, reopening schools, expanding seminaries, renewing monasteries, and in general restoring the outward signs of Russian Orthodox religious life.


But Kirill, who was the key figure behind the unprecedented promulgation of the Church's social teaching in a document in the year 2000, can also be expected to take bold new steps to go beyond renewing the institutional structure of the Church.

Kirill wants to affect society.


The new Patriarch, who has for several years had his own Sunday morning television show, wants the voice of the Church, the voice of Christian teaching and Christian values, to be heard in contemporary Russia on the great questions facing the country and the world -- in economics, in law, in family life, in education, in social reform projects, in culture.

Kirill, a powerful public speaker, has been extremely active in recent years, traveling the world from Indonesia to Brazil, from Rome to Havana to Geneva, to preach and build friendships in dozens of countries. (He did this in his role as the "Foreign Minister" of the Russian Orthodox Church, heading up the Church's External Relations Department.)

It is not clear whether this type of travel will also mark his patriarchate, but it is certain that it will be a patriarchate with a global scope. It could not be otherwise, considering his life experience in recent years.


One great question concerns his relations with the Pope of Rome and with the Roman Catholic Church in general. It seems certain that Kirill, who has traveled several times to Rome and has met with Pope Benendict XVI more than once, will invite Benedict to visit Russia -- something Pope John Paul II wished to do but was not able to due to the unwillingness of Patriarch Alexi to receive him.


"Kirill has a keen sense of the important role of religious institutions in public life," said Daniel Schmidt, an American philanthropist who has met and spoken at length with Kirill. "He recognizes the essential role of religious faith, not just in his own country, but in human society in general, in building social trust," Schmidt, director of programs for the Bradley Foundation of Milwaukee, Wisconsin, said. The foundation has supported many Russian youth centers, orphanages, clinics and schools over the past 10 years.

Kirill's election, then, may usher in a time when the Russian Church will be more open to collaboration and common efforts, in Russia and worldwide, with the Catholic Church, and with others as well.

Kirill, who has already been serving for eight weeks as "interim Patriarch" (he was chosen by his fellow bishops to carry out the duties of patriarch after the death of Alexi II on December 5), made his mind clear in a homily he delivered on January 6 at a Christmas Eve Mass held at the Cathedral of Christ the Savior (following the Julian calendar, the Russian Orthodox Church celebrates Christmas on January 7).

More than 3,000 attended the Mass, including Russian President Dimitry Medvedev, accompanied by his wife, Prime Minister Vladimir Putin, and hundreds of other dignitaries, as well as the Pope's nuncio, or ambassador, to Russia, Italian Archbishop Antonio Mennini.

Kirill invited those present to be valiant during the current economic crisis, and asked for spiritual help for the nation's president.

The word "crisis" comes from the Greek meaning "decision," Kirill said. He said that today decisions have been affected by certain attitudes, such as "greed, loss of control over consumption, a bid to enrich oneself by all means and have as much as possible." He said the crisis began when people forgot true values, and that further crises could be avoided if values provided the foundation for the economy.

"Today we recall how the Son of God came down to people so that each one of us could rejoin Him. But to allow this to happen, there must be a response on our part, response worthy of divine love -- our own love, active and sacrificial, " Kirill said.

The life of the deceased Patriarch Alexi II was an example of such love, he said, praising the late Patriarch's relentless efforts aimed at preserving the unity of Church.

"The demise of the Holy Patriarch Alexi ends an important period in the history of our Church, which coincided with deep social changes," Kirill said. "We are now living in an entirely different society that bears no resemblance to the times of imposed atheism."

At the same time, the Patriarchal Locum Tenens acknowledged that Orthodox Christians in Russia are now facing new problems, mostly of social and economic nature.

Many are losing their jobs and sustaining "material losses, Kirill said.

"The Church embraces with compassion all who are finding it hard to carry on," he said. "May God give strength and wisdom to all -- rulers, entrepreneurs and ordinary workers -- so that our common and coordinated efforts, mutual support and the search for correct decisions could help us surmount the current difficulties, preserve ourselves and our loved ones and maintain peace and harmony in our society."

Kirill told believers that "only love creates real unity".

"Only if there is no room left for enmity, envy or rivalry in our souls and our hearts are open to love and unity will God's blessings descend upon us, healing our ailments and filling us with strength," he said.

The Christmas address prepared by Patriarch Alexi II before his death was also read at the Christmas Mass. Alexi recalled in his message the celebrations that took place last June 2008 to mark 1020 years of Christianity in Russia (the country's baptism occurred in 988), and he invited the faithful to continue living according to the will of God, and not their own.

“Let us remember," Alexy II wrote, "that only God gives true peace.”

Traditional Values

Kirill, and others who believe as he does, is controversial in the West, especially because has made strong statements condemning societal acceptance of homosexuality.

In an interview published in mid-2008 by the German magazine Der Spiegel, Kirill said that if society stops considering homosexuality a sin, the next step will be general excuse of various sexual perversions.

Reminding the interviewer that the Bible calls homosexuality a sin, Metropolitan Kirill stressed that the Church does not condemn homosexuals and is against "persecuting or insulting these people."

But, he continued, "why promote sin? A gay parade is an intrusive display of depravity. The Church is to say that sin is sin. Otherwise, the Church is not needed."

In March, 2007, Kirill denounced the idea of conducting a gay pride parade in Moscow. He said it "is directed against the majority of Russian society. We believe that the law should not interfere in citizens' private lives. You can sin if you want to, but you will answer to God. However, if you are trying to propagate your sin by seducing and degrading people, society must oppose it."

In an address to the Third European Ecumenical Assembly in Sibiu in September, 2007, Kirill said that in order for Europe to survive the tribulations that have befallen previous civilizations, it must retain its Christian identity.

He said an increasing number of Europeans Christians and non-Christians alike have come to recognize "Christianity [as] a powerful source of support for European civilization. "

He was careful to explain that this does not imply that "there is no room" in Europe "for people of other religions and with other outlooks on the world." Rather, it points to the "recognition of the high role of the Christian faith in the past, present and future of our continent."


Kirill seems poised to strive to lessen the rift between the Russian Orthodox and Catholic Churches.



Kirill has said that "in the Vatican and not only in the Vatican but all over the world, Catholics understand that Orthodox (people) are their allies. And Orthodox (people) are more and more coming to understand that Catholics are their allies in the face of hostile and non-religious secularism."
But some Russian Orthodox think he is going too far, and this will provide a brake against Kirill's ecumenical efforts. On 31 December Pravaya.ru published an open letter taking Kirill to task for ties with the Roman Catholic Church. The letter asked him to renounce statements it says he had made in the past. First among them, states the letter: "We ask you to disavow the assertion that the Orthodox and Roman Catholic churches are divided parts of One Church, and affirm that in the true sense the One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church is only the Orthodox Church."

The letter cites an interview Kirill gave in 1991, in which he stated that no ecumenical council, similar to those that established Church doctrine in the early centuries of Christianity, has been convened since the division of the churches to formally condemn the resulting religions as heretical.


In a defence of Kirill published on 13 January in response to the open letter, Russian Orthodox Bishop Hilarion of Vienna and Austria cited interviews, sermons and documents in which Kirill disavowed the "branch theory" of Christianity.


"The goal of branding someone with whom one does not agree as a heretic is not, of course, to find the truth, but to blacken one's opponent," Hilarion wrote. "When this is done on the threshold of a local council that will be electing the Patriarch, and in regards to one of the possible candidates, then it is clear this is not a search for truth but a sinful means of fighting an undesirable person."


The delegates named by each diocese to attend the local council, and the process of selecting them have also stirred heated debated. It has been noted that bureaucrats and others with close ties to power, are among the delegates, including the governor of the Omsk region, the wife of the governor of Primorsky Krai, on Russia's Pacific coast, and a number of businessmen.


Metropolitan Kliment of Kaluga and Borovsk, the Moscow Patriarchate' s property manager, who was seen as less enthusiastic on church unity than Kirill, was the remaining candidate. Metropolitan Filaret of Minsk had been seen as one of the favorites, but there were concerns about his health, and Filaret himself removed himself from consideration prior to the vote, asking those present to vote for Kirill.


"Under this holy man, the Russian Orthodox Church became the only force preserving the traditions and values of holy Russia," Kirill said in Moscow's Christ the Savior Cathedral. "Like a sick man, allowed to stand after a long period in bed, our Church was weak at the beginning of his service and unable to use its spiritual potential fully. Today, it is no longer weak, and it lives with the people," he told participants in the December 9 service.

Among those in attendance were Russian President Dmitry Medvedev and Prime Minister Vladimir Putin, as well as Orthodox patriarchs and archbishops and leaders of other faiths and denominations. Among the Catholics attending were German Cardinal Walter Kasper, president of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, and French Cardinal Roger Etchegaray, retired head of the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace.

MOSCOW (AFP) — The Russian Orthodox Church on Tuesday selected 62-year-old Metropolitan Kirill as its new patriarch, an outspoken figure who analysts say could prove a headache for the Kremlin.

A seasoned operator after long service as head of the church's foreign relations section, Kirill was elected by an overwhelming majority in a ballot of church leaders in Moscow's ornate cathedral of Christ the Saviour.

Kirill, Metropolitan of Smolensk and Kaliningrad, received 508 votes in a secret ballot of the Church Council in Moscow while his challenger Metropolitan Kliment of Kaluga and Borovsk won 169 votes.

"I accept and thank the Church Council for my election as Patriarch of Moscow and All Russia," Kirill said solemnly after the results were announced, before leading the congregation in an Orthodox liturgy.

Addressing the incense-filled gathering earlier, Kirill had made a strident call for church unity and urged the faithful to resist Protestant and Catholic proselytizing, dampening hopes of a transformation in poisonous ties with Rome.

About 700 bearded and robed bishops and laity from both Russia and diocese abroad had the right to participate in the first such vote of the post-Soviet era, following the death of Alexy II last month.

Gathered outside on the freezing Moscow street were about 100 of the faithful, some holding banners and icons and chanting.

Kirill's comments echoed the tough approach of his predecessor, who resisted attempts by late Polish pope John Paul II to reach out to Catholics in ex-Soviet lands and who refused to countenance a papal visit to Russia.

In the post-Soviet era "the most active proselytizing was by missionaries of all manner of Protestant denominations but we also noticed with bitterness representatives of the Catholic hierarchy," Kirill said.

"We must attentively follow developments and where necessary quickly and decisively react to threats," added Kirill, who after Alexy's death was appointed "Guardian of the Throne" temporarily in charge of the church.

Metropolitan Kirill, who has hosted his own weekly television programme "Words of a Pastor" for the past 10 years, is seen as something of a loose cannon in political circles, analysts say.

"Among the bishops, he's the only real politician. If I were president, I'd be afraid of such a man," said religious affairs expert Sergei Filatov of the Russian Academy of Sciences, referring to Kirill.

Russia's politicians "can't tell what he's going to do. If (the economy) all goes pear shaped they don't know what Patriarch Kirill would do. They'd prefer someone they had control over," said religious affairs analyst and journalist for the Forum 18 religious news agency Geraldine Fagan earlier.

Kirill, whose crushing victory had been widely predicted, takes over a church that went from strength to strength under Alexy after being repressed in the Soviet era.

Prime Minister Putin and President Dmitry Medvedev both attend church on feast days, as do other Slavic leaders such as Belarus' President Alexander Lukashenko.

The church's relatively rapid election of Kirill, without resorting to a run-off, and the withdrawal of a third candidate just before voting began were indicative of its desire to make a show of unity at a crucial moment.

The Cathedral of Christ the Saviour is a symbol of the church's resurgence. Dynamited under Stalin, it was then replaced by an open air swimming pool before an exact replica was rebuilt in the 1990s.

In an interview with the Trud newspaper published Monday, Kirill said the church was thriving but could still play a greater role in daily life, including education.