acolytejim,
You bring up some issues for consideration. I can only speak to the reasons why I am planning to attend the AHS program and not the BC Seminary program.
Has anyone ever heard of the Byz. Cath. seminary?????? They offer Master's degrees for the laity in theology!
Yes - and I share your excitement. I believe the faculty at St. Cyril and Methodius Seminary is top notch, and the program looks very thorough.
Here is a link to the program:
http://www.byzcathsem.org/seminary/degree.php I am also a BIG FAN of the Metropolitan Sheptytsky Institute in Ottawa. It offers civil and ecclesiatical degrees, including the only pontifical degree program in Eastern Christian Studies in North America.
http://web.ustpaul.uottawa.ca/Sheptytsky/programs/programs_main.htm Why would you not rather support our archeparchy by attending there rather than the Antiochenes????
You are making some assumptions here. One is that I would prefer, all things being equal, a particular Orthodox jurisdiction's program to an Eastern Catholic program. If the Byzantine Catholic Seminary offered its program through a distance learning cohort model with an abbreviated residency requirement, I would seriously consider it. My hope would be that any differences would be minimal, since we are, after all, Orthodox Christians in unity with Rome!
I would also point out that the Melkites have elected to send their seminarians to Holy Cross Orthodox Seminary in Brookline, MA.
Alas, Jim, not everyone is as fortunate as you to live in Western Pennsylvania to take advantage of such local programs. The St. Stephen's Program is designed to educate and equip Eastern Christians who live outside of a 90 mile radius of Pittsburgh and are unable to uproot their families to study there. My hope is that the BC seminary will someday explore that option, especially in light of advances in DL methodologies and tools that have developed overthe years.
Our seminary seems to be the way to go for Byz. Caths. and they accept women as well as men.
Excellent, but again only women and men who either already live in Pittsburgh or the surrounding area or plan to move there. Not helpful to me or others.
It is a little more $$$ than the St. Stephen's but it is a better masters.
Actually, if you compare the programs, I believe that St. Stephen's is substantially LESS $$$. Since I have not taken either program (nor, I assume, have you) I can only speak to what I have been told by others. The St. Stephen's Program is evidently very well done, has top notch professors and maintains academic rigor in the program. (Having read Father Joseph Allen, he alone is reason to attend this program. Add to that names like Tarazi and Meyendorff, and you've got some pretty heavy hitters. Evidently our sister Church in the OCA finds this program effective for diaconal formation, so I'm not sure what standards you are using.
They offer an option where you can go to Duquesne and the seminary and get a good degree from a regionally accredited school!
Wow - you really get excited about these things! Duquesne is "grand" as the Irish say. I've had many friends and associates who have studied there, and felt it was a challenging, first-rate program. Again, distance is the key differentiator.
The degree from the antiochian house of studies is from the university of Balamand????
You seem to suffer from EPD (Excessive Punctuation Disorder)!!!!!!! Yes - the University of Balamand in Lebanon. Quite a school. Patriarch Ignatius IV of Antioch was once the Dean of the Seminary there - and he is no intellectual slouch.
Not even a U.S. accredited univ. If you plan on further studies beyond the masters, and don't want to do their doctorate degree, which is in ministry and for priests, any good regionally accredited school would laugh!!!!!!!!!!!!
To quote Ronald Reagan, "there you go again"! Usually you need to hit the key once and release to make your point.............
What was your point anyway? Oh yes - I was distracted by endless punctuation!

You assume, Jim, that all of us plan to go for our doctorates in theology. Perhaps we just want to be grounded in our heritage as Eastern Christians and are unable (or unwilling) to uproot everything familiar and move to Shangri-la (aka Pittsburgh, PA) to pay more for formation to help be more effective teachers, catechists, evangelists, husbands, wives, fathers, mothers, monastics, employees, or (maybe someday) clergy. Theological formation is principally for the sanctfication of the individual - the mind and the heart - and to equip them to be apostles. If this will help me be holier and more effective in my apostolates, what is your issue?
Based upon my own research, the structure and content of the program, my own circumstances as well as the list high quality faculty at AHS, I'm comfortable investing my time, energy, resources, etc etc into my education through St. Stephen's. It matters not one iota that some committee of a regional accrediting agency has not placed its seal of approval on AHS.
Just to remind you of Father Anthony's post on this:
Now for the others wondering about accreditation. ATS is only one accrediting body and then for only those seminaries that are generally imparting "Divinity" degrees. There is Eastern States, Middle States etc. that also accredit, along with individual state agencies. St. John of Damascus School of Theology of the University of Balamand is not only internationally recognized but accredited on par with schools such as the University of Athens and the University of Thessaloniki. I have to remind some of our posters that most Catholic universities do NOT hold ATS accreditation, but are accredited by some other body. I also would like to point out that Christ the Savior, Holy Trinity, Saint Herman's, and Saint Sophia Seminaries are not on the ATS list, but hold state or other accreditation. These schools still educate candidates for Holy Orders despite lacking this accrediatation, generally by being teamed up with another college to suppliment their programs.
So......
Best of luck to you in your own higher education pursuits out there in Western Pennsylvania, Jim. So will you be studying in Rome or Navarre for your own doctoral work???????????????????
Gordo
